Bathtub and Shower in One Bathroom — Is It Worth It?

When planning a bathroom renovation, one of the most common questions homeowners face is whether to include both a bathtub and a shower, or choose just one. The answer depends on your lifestyle, space, and long-term plans for the home. Here’s what to consider before making the decision.

Pros of Having Both a Bathtub and a Shower

1. Versatility for Different Needs. A separate shower is great for daily use—quick, efficient, and practical. A bathtub, on the other hand, offers a relaxing retreat after a long day. Having both gives you flexibility depending on your mood and schedule.

2. Increased Home Value. Homes with both features in the primary or guest bathroom often appeal to a broader range of buyers, especially families with young children or future homeowners who value having a soaking option. This setup can boost your home’s resale value and marketability.

3. Aesthetic and Design Impact. Modern bathrooms with both a freestanding tub and a walk-in shower tend to feel luxurious and high-end. When designed well, they can transform a functional space into a spa-like experience.

Cons to Consider

1. Space Requirements. Not all bathrooms can comfortably fit both a shower and a tub without feeling crowded. If space is limited, combining them into a single unit or prioritizing one feature may be a smarter move.

2. Budget Impact. Installing both a tub and a separate shower requires more materials, plumbing work, and time—so the cost will generally be higher. It’s important to weigh the value of the added functionality against your renovation budget.

3. MaintenanceMore fixtures mean more surfaces to clean and maintain. Depending on the materials you choose, this could be a minor or major factor.

When It Makes Sense to Do Both

• You have the space to comfortably accommodate both without compromising flow

• You plan to stay in your home long-term and want to enjoy both options

• You're designing a primary or guest bathroom with future resale in mind

• You want a high-end look and are investing in a full remodel

  
  

Final Thoughts

Including both a bathtub and a shower in one bathroom can add comfort, function, and long-term value—if your space and budget allow for it. At First Round Construction, we help homeowners design smart, beautiful bathrooms that match their needs and lifestyle.

Still not sure what works best for your space? We’re here to help you weigh the options and build the bathroom that’s right for you.